Home Best Commander stores Indiana

Ranked by sourced data

Best Commander stores in Indiana

Top 25 of 93 Indiana stores with a weekly Commander night we can cite, out of 140 listed. Ranked by what we can verify, not by star ratings. How the ranking works.

All Indiana stores Methodology

  1. The Castle Games - Bloomington

    Bloomington, IN

    MTWTFSSMon 2 PM Casual Commander · +6 more
    Score 16 · why
    • +15 7 weekly Commander nights (max 5 counted)
    • +1 Public Discord

  2. UpScale Hobbies & Gaming

    Sellersburg, IN

    MTWTFSSTue 2 PM Casual Commander · +5 more
    Score 16 · why
    • +15 6 weekly Commander nights (max 5 counted)
    • +1 Public Discord

  3. D20 Dungeon

    Muncie, IN

    MTWTFSSWed 6 PM Midweek Magic · +3 more
    Bracket: 3Beginner-friendly: yes
    Score 16 · why
    • +12 4 weekly Commander nights
    • +4 Published bracket, beginner-friendly

  4. Element Null Gaming

    Scottsburg, IN

    MTWTFSSMon 12 PM Casual Play · +6 more
    Score 15 · why
    • +15 7 weekly Commander nights (max 5 counted)

  5. Bulldog Community Gaming

    Brownsburg, IN

    MTWTFSSTue 7 PM Casual Commander · +3 more
    Beginner-friendly: yes
    Score 15 · why
    • +12 4 weekly Commander nights
    • +2 Published beginner-friendly
    • +1 Public Discord

  6. Alt Art TCG

    Muncie, IN · Verified by store

    MTWTFSSMon 5:30 PM Monday Night Magic
    Proxies: restrictedBracket: mixedBeginner-friendly: yes
    Score 15 · why
    • +3 1 weekly Commander night
    • +6 Verified by the store
    • +6 Published proxy policy, bracket, beginner-friendly

  7. GameQuest

    Fort Wayne, IN

    MTWTFSSMon 6 PM GameQuest Commander Pods · +3 more
    Score 12 · why
    • +12 4 weekly Commander nights

  8. Round Table Games and Curt's Cafe

    Fort Wayne, IN

    MTWTFSSWed 6 PM Casual EDH Pods · +3 more
    Score 12 · why
    • +12 4 weekly Commander nights

  9. Schmoley's Games and More

    Crown Point, IN

    MTWTFSSThu 7 PM Casual Commander · +2 more
    Bracket: 4
    Score 11 · why
    • +9 3 weekly Commander nights
    • +2 Published bracket

  10. By the Board Games and Entertainment

    Lowell, IN

    MTWTFSSTue 5 PM BTB Casual Commander Nights · +2 more
    Score 10 · why
    • +9 3 weekly Commander nights
    • +1 Public Discord

  11. Play Test Lounge

    Carmel, IN

    MTWTFSSMon 6:30 PM Commander Night at Play Test Lounge · +2 more
    Score 10 · why
    • +9 3 weekly Commander nights
    • +1 Public Discord

  12. DZ Gaming

    Decatur, IN

    MTWTFSSThu 5 PM Commander Night · +2 more
    Score 9 · why
    • +9 3 weekly Commander nights

  13. Next Level Games - Carmel

    Carmel, IN

    MTWTFSSFri 5 PM Casual Commander Weekends · +2 more
    Score 9 · why
    • +9 3 weekly Commander nights

  14. Next Level Games - Muncie

    Muncie, IN

    MTWTFSSFri 5 PM Casual Commander · +2 more
    Score 9 · why
    • +9 3 weekly Commander nights

  15. Power Nine Gaming

    Fort Wayne, IN

    MTWTFSSMon 6 PM Commander · +2 more
    Score 9 · why
    • +9 3 weekly Commander nights

  16. Tier 1 Games - Lafayette

    Lafayette, IN

    MTWTFSSMon 6 PM Commander Monday · +2 more
    Score 9 · why
    • +9 3 weekly Commander nights

  17. Secret Door Games

    Elkhart, IN

    MTWTFSSThu 7 PM Commander · +1 more
    Beginner-friendly: yes
    Score 9 · why
    • +6 2 weekly Commander nights
    • +2 Published beginner-friendly
    • +1 Public Discord

  18. Dragons Castle Gaming

    Elwood, IN

    MTWTFSSFri 1 PM Friday Night Magic friday night magic · +1 more
    Beginner-friendly: yes
    Score 8 · why
    • +6 2 weekly Commander nights
    • +2 Published beginner-friendly

  19. Moonshot Games

    Noblesville, IN

    MTWTFSSTue 6 PM Tuesday Night Open Play Commander · +1 more
    Beginner-friendly: yes
    Score 8 · why
    • +6 2 weekly Commander nights
    • +2 Published beginner-friendly

  20. Atomic Planet Comics

    Fishers, IN

    MTWTFSSThu 3 PM Casual Commander · +1 more
    Score 7 · why
    • +6 2 weekly Commander nights
    • +1 Public Discord

  21. Elf N Moon

    Indianapolis, IN

    MTWTFSSMon 11 AM Fractured Moons · +1 more
    Score 7 · why
    • +6 2 weekly Commander nights
    • +1 Opening hours on record

  22. Gray Gauntlet Games

    Indianapolis, IN

    MTWTFSSWed 5 PM Commander Open Play · +1 more
    Score 7 · why
    • +6 2 weekly Commander nights
    • +1 Public Discord

  23. Table Games

    Richmond, IN

    MTWTFSSWed 4 PM Commander Night · +1 more
    Score 7 · why
    • +6 2 weekly Commander nights
    • +1 Public Discord

  24. Hidden Realm Cards

    Elkhart, IN

    MTWTFSSFri 6 PM Friday Night Magic Commander Tournament
    Bracket: 3Beginner-friendly: yes
    Score 7 · why
    • +3 1 weekly Commander night
    • +4 Published bracket, beginner-friendly

  25. A&A Games

    Franklin, IN

    MTWTFSSFri 5 PM Friday Night Magic Casual Play · +1 more
    Score 6 · why
    • +6 2 weekly Commander nights

Weekly digest

Commander nights near Indiana

One short email a week: Commander nights in and around Indiana, stores that just got verified, and proxy or bracket changes. Free, unsubscribe anytime.

We keep your email private and only use it for this digest. We never sell it. Unsubscribe in any email. Privacy · Terms